The Psychotherapy of Schizophrenia: Does It Work?
JARL E. DYRUD M.D.1, and
PHILIP S. HOLZMAN PH.D.2
1 Professor of Psychiatry, Department of Psychiatry, University of Chicago, 950 East 59th St., Chicago, Ill. 60637
2 Professor of Psychology and Psychiatry, Department of Psychiatry, University of Chicago, 950 East 59th St., Chicago, Ill. 60637
Empirical studies of the treatment of schizophrenia show the unequivocal ameliorative effects of psychoactive drugs. No comparable effects have been claimed for psychotherapy. As a result, psychotherapy has tended to be negated as a viable therapeutic factor in the treatment of schizophrenia. Yet the sophisticated drug evaluation studies are not matched by sophisticated assessments of psychotherapy. Serious methodological errors exist in the latter studies; there have been inappropriate outcome criteria, inadequate assessment procedures to measure change, unsound selection of therapists, and unclear diagnostic appraisals. The issue has been further clouded by the heterogeneous nature of psychotherapeutic interventions, comprising as they do—in contrast to the relatively simple administration of drugs—a congeries of methods, techniques, and goals. This paper examines some of the requirements for appropriate evaluation studies of psychotherapy of schizophrenic patients.
