THE EMPTY NEST: PSYCHOSOCIAL ASPECTS OF CONFLICT BETWEEN DEPRESSED WOMEN AND THEIR GROWN CHILDREN
EVA Y. DEYKIN M.S.1,
SHIRLEY JACOBSON 1,
MAIDA SOLOMON 2, , and
GERALD KLERMAN M.D.3
1 Psychiatric Social Worker, Massachusetts Mental Health Center, 74 Fenwood Road, Boston
2 Consultant in Psychiatric Research Social Work, Massachusetts Mental Health Center, 74 Fenwood Road, Boston
3 Associate Professor of Psychiatry, Yale University, New Haven, Conn.
In summary, the 14 empty nest patients studied in detail were women who entered the hospital with a comparable degree of depression. They all shared a common inability to deal successfully with the termination of child rearing and had difficulty in adjusting to their status as childless mothers. In half the sample, consisting of seven overt conflict patients, the difficulty was characterized by violent and frequent arguments with their children. In the seven latent conflict patients, the difficulty found expression in a vague, undefined kind of dissatisfaction.
The kind of conflict manifested by the total sample seemed to be related, in part, to a number of social and environmental characteristics. A higher education, postponement of pregnancy for a year or more after marriage, espousal of American values and traditions, friends outside the family, satisfying work experience and, most important of all, the presence of a husband were all consistent with the manifestation of latent conflict between the patients and their children.
Conversely, a grade school education, early marriages followed almost immediately by pregnancy, adherence to European traditions, few or no friends outside the family, no work experience and the absence of a husband were all factors associated with overt conflict. While the sample of this pilot study is too small to draw any firm conclusions regarding the impact of the cessation of child rearing on all depressed patients, our findings suggest that it is important to differentiate the extent and locus of conflict in the relationship between depressed women and their children. The reestablishment of a healthy relationship depends in large measure on the careful diagnosis of the existing conflict, which in turn dictates the type of therapy to be undertaken.
