OBJECTIVE: The authors reviewed data involving the impact of providing
psychotherapy for psychiatric disorders on costs of care. METHOD: In a
search of the MEDLINE database limited to peer-reviewed papers published
from 1984 through 1994, 686 articles were identified. Forty- one articles,
covering 35 studies, were found in which the intervention tested was
psychotherapeutic and the study included measures of outcome that had some
implications for cost. The exclusion criteria for reviewing these studies
included absence of a comparison group, a focus on medical disorders
instead of psychiatric illnesses, and outcomes that did not include cost
data or measures from which costs could be inferred. On this basis, 18 of
the 35 studies were selected for analysis. The studies were categorized
according to whether or not subjects were randomly assigned to study
groups. Two reviewers independently read each study to identify the
following characteristics: inclusion criteria, exclusion criteria, types of
interventions, main outcome variables, sample size, and statistical tests
for significant differences between treatments. Outcomes had to include
actual cost accounting or data on medical care utilization or work
functioning. RESULTS: The findings of eight (80%) of the 10 clinical trials
with random assignment and all eight (100%) of the studies without random
assignment suggested that psychotherapy reduces total costs. CONCLUSIONS:
Psychotherapy appears to have a beneficial impact on a variety of costs
when used in the treatment of the most severe psychiatric disorders,
including schizophrenia, bipolar affective disorder, and borderline
personality disorder. Much of that impact accrues from reductions in
inpatient treatment and decreases in work impairment.
Abstract Teaser