OBJECTIVE: The purpose of this comparative outcome study was to
investigate whether the effects of exposure in vivo treatment for panic
disorder with agoraphobia could be enhanced by adding interventions
specifically for panic attacks before the start of exposure treatment. The
additional effect of two types of treatment for panic attacks--
pharmacological (fluvoxamine) and psychological (repeated hyperventilation
provocations and respiratory training)--was examined. Thus, the combined
treatment of panic interventions with exposure in vivo could be compared to
exposure in vivo alone. METHOD: Ninety-six patients were randomly assigned
to four treatment conditions: double- blind, placebo-controlled fluvoxamine
followed by exposure in vivo, psychological panic management followed by
exposure, and exposure in vivo alone. Outcome was assessed by self-report
measures, a standardized multitask behavioral avoidance test, and
continuous monitoring of panic attacks. Seventy-six patients completed the
study. RESULTS: All four treatments were effective and resulted in a
significant decrease of agoraphobic avoidance. Moreover, the combination of
fluvoxamine and exposure in vivo demonstrated efficacy superior to that of
the other treatments and had twice as large an effect size (difference
between pre- and posttreatment scores) on self- reported agoraphobic
avoidance. The other treatments did not differ among each other in
effectiveness. CONCLUSIONS: Results of the study indicate that the
short-term outcome of exposure in vivo treatment can be enhanced by adding
fluvoxamine treatment. Psychological panic management combined with
exposure was not superior to exposure alone of equal duration.
Abstract Teaser