OBJECTIVE: The purpose of this study was to evaluate whether ECT causes
structural brain damage. METHOD: The literature review covered the
following areas: cognitive side effects, structural brain imaging,
autopsies of patients who had received ECT, post-mortem studies of
epileptic subjects, animal studies of electroconvulsive shock (ECS) and
epilepsy, and the neuropathological effects of the passage of electricity,
heat generation, and blood-brain barrier disruption. RESULTS: ECT-induced
cognitive deficits are transient, although spotty memory loss may persist
for events immediately surrounding the ECT course. Prospective computerized
tomography and magnetic resonance imaging studies show no evidence of
ECT-induced structural changes. Some early human autopsy case reports from
the unmodified ECT era reported cerebrovascular lesions that were due to
agonal changes or undiagnosed disease. In animal ECS studies that used a
stimulus intensity and frequency comparable to human ECT, no neuronal loss
was seen when appropriate control animals, blind ratings, and perfusion
fixation techniques were employed. Controlled studies using quantitative
cell counts have failed to show neuronal loss even after prolonged courses
of ECS. Several well-controlled studies have demonstrated that neuronal
loss occurs only after 1.5 to 2 hours of continuous seizure activity in
primates, and adequate muscle paralysis and oxygenation further delay these
changes. These conditions are not approached during ECT. Other findings
indicate that the passage of electricity, thermal effects, and the
transient disruption of the blood- brain barrier during ECS do not result
in structural brain damage. CONCLUSIONS: There is no credible evidence that
ECT causes structural brain damage.
Abstract Teaser