OBJECTIVE: The purpose of this study was to examine the predictive
effect of the clinical activity of patients' alcohol use on the course of
major depressive disorder. METHOD: One hundred seventy-six probands with
Research Diagnostic Criteria (RDC) diagnoses of both major depressive
disorder and alcoholism were compared to 412 probands with major depressive
disorder only by using 10 years of short-interval, prospective follow-up
data collected as part of the National Institute of Mental Health
Collaborative Depression Study. The course of depression was examined by
using intensity analysis to represent transitions between states of major
depressive disorder. The effect of patients' RDC alcoholism status on the
long-term course of major depressive disorder was examined by stratifying
the analyses by three levels of alcoholism--never alcoholic, not meeting
criteria for current alcoholism, and current alcoholism. RESULTS: Depressed
probands who were either never alcoholic or currently nonactive alcoholic
had twice the likelihood of recovery from major depressive disorder than
did actively alcoholic depressed probands. The three levels of alcoholism
did not differentially predict recurrence of major depressive disorder.
CONCLUSIONS: These findings provide long-term, empirically derived evidence
for the deleterious effect of current alcoholism on recovery from
depression. The lack of a differential effect of the three levels of
alcoholism on recurrence of major depressive disorder suggests that other
factors may have greater predictive value.
Abstract Teaser