Rates of long-term abstinence from cigarette smoking are only 20%–35% for the most widely accepted treatments. Hall et al. (p.
2100) tried a comprehensive, long-term approach to smoking cessation and achieved an abstinence rate of 50%. Four groups of smokers all received group counseling for 12 weeks, attempted to quit smoking at week 5, and used nicotine patches during weeks 5–12. Two of the groups took nortriptyline, and two took placebo. After this brief program, one of the nortriptyline groups and one of the placebo groups received 40 additional weeks of treatment with monthly individual counseling, telephone contacts, and the nortriptyline or placebo. The long-term combination of drug and psychological treatments produced the 50.0% 1-year abstinence rate, but extended counseling plus placebo produced a rate of 41.5%. In relation to the cost of most medical interventions, counseling, telephone contacts, and nortriptyline are inexpensive. The combination is a bargain when viewed against the high health care costs of tobacco use.
+